A Visit to Stewart’s Melville College in Scotland

A guest post by AASA President Gail Pletnick

[Pictured left to right: AASA President Gail Pletnick; AASA Executive Director Dan Domenech; AASA Past President Amy Sichel.]

A visit to Stewart’s Melville College in Edinburgh allowed us to get a close look at education at this private school for students (boys) ages 12-17. The school grounds were beautiful and the building radiated tradition.

The boys were smartly dressed in school uniforms that distinguished their rank or grade level at the school. The library had old stained glass windows and the woodwork was incredible. At the same time, we saw modern physical education facilities including a competition-sized pool.

This mix of very traditional and more current was also reflected in the instruction we saw in classrooms. Our tour guides were two young gentlemen who were in their final year at the school. They wanted to show us everything this private school represented and offered.

One of our first stops was in a language arts classroom where the teacher was teaching a math lesson because he felt strongly this was an area where students were not as well prepared as they should be. He expressed his view that students performed well on the required tests because the test was too easy. In that classroom we observed the teacher sitting at his desk and students assigned problems to solve. Some students were engaged and others appeared disengaged.

As we moved to another room where history was taught, our student tour guides became animated and shared how the teachers in this department used innovative teaching techniques, including taking on the persona of a historical figure, dressing as that person and surprising students with their presence in the classroom. The students spoke of never forgetting those lessons.

We all know that teachers are the first and most important connection between the student and learning. The physical environment and the resources available do impact learning. However, the human resource we call teacher is the key.

In the Stewart’s Melville College and in the ESMS private school system that this school belongs to, teachers are paid approximately 10 percent more than in the government-funded schools. That is certainly an advantage. However, as observed in some schools, money alone cannot guarantee the best instruction. Once again, we find location or a school’s category does not seem to matter when we are speaking about the fundamentals that drive quality education and one of those most critical components is a highly skilled and caring teacher.


Gail Pletnick is the superintendent of the Dysart Unified School District in Surprise, Ariz., and the 2017-18 president of AASA, The School Superintendents Association. She is participating in the AASA International Seminar in Scotland.